OUR NETWORK:MediaSmart Home Sansa Community Explore3DTV TechLore RoboCommunity Dijit Community About UsAdvertiseContact Us

 
Learn about scoring Forum's Raw Score: 580265.0
November 14, 2008 04:08 AM

Categories: News, Rumors and Gossip

Rating (0 votes)
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Rate This!

Member Avatar

gunnar-iq

Member
Joined: 11/12/2008

Hello I saw the IQ512 (500 series) have entered consumer retail in Sweden, sold in many of the electronic store outlets.

It was kind of a Deja Vu for me to discover this product, I came to think of the Sony 'all-in-one' desktops (PCV-W10,W20,W30) that were a fresh cosmethic departure from the stereotype computer system appearance when it came out many years ago (Pentium 4 days) although here we have touch and considerable more sophistication..
 

 

 I tried it out briefly in the shop.  The Photo Album functionality worked smooth and slick,

however the *main* Touchsmart interface (the main one with bigger upper line of tiles and a smaller line of tiles underneath) had some problems with jerky motion when dragged. I don't know if there exists settings for changing how the touch interaction works with the touchsmart graphics when dragged ?

As it appeared, when the user drags the finger on screen the graphics attempts to move promptly tied to each coordinate change, and performance isn't up to having that appear in an exact flow but some lag occurs here and there where the graphics has to catch up with finger motion, thus jerkiness.

I would rather prefer a "rubber banding" relation to the finger position so that the graphics move decoupled from the exact finger coordinates but move smoothly in the direction of the finger movement. This gives a more sophisticated feel to the whole experience.  Again; I am not sure if there are settings to tweak of if HP are doing revisions that improve on this ?

That issue is actually at the heart of Touchsmart market success since the customer first impression in the store is what's going to sell the product.

Anyway; bold move by HP and a refreshing alternative to the desktop box models that have looked the same for decades.

 The most common question I see appear in consumer forums regarding this concept is:

"Does it have a video output" ?   People figure it would be cool if they could connect it to their big screen living room plasma or projector over HDMI or DVI to play movies on their ordinary big screen.   (As they would if they bought some conventional PC such as all the other ones in the shop). The market penetration of flat screen TV's is massive over here, almost everyone own one in some kind of size.  People with existing living room TV's might not move over to a 22" as their only screen. So they will end up with two independent systems. Apparently the TouchSmart IQ design philosophy does not include an external monitor use case. Maybe somebody can elaborate on what forces that design choice ?

A workaround for that case could be connecting the IQ to a Media center "tank" for such output. Such as a Popcorn Hour A110 or similar over USB or Ethernet, but I don't know the usability caveats from doing that.

Discussion:    Add a Comment | Comments 1-5 of 5 | Latest Comment

November 14, 2008 1:36 PM

Hi Gunnar-iq, trevligt att rĂ¥kas (swedish). I could not agree with you more. Every other hardware and software out there are all trying to network/interface/connect to other systems - but not the touchsmart :-(

The "touch interaction" is exactly as you described - jerky and then it goes bananas and everything flyes away...

This nice piece of equipment is a "stand alone" - period!

When it comes to watching movies, photos, etc on the big screen in the livingroom - nothing beats the combination of PS3/AppleTV. The TouchSmart stays in the kitchen..

November 15, 2008 3:19 PM updated: November 16, 2008 4:24 AM

This is terrible, glossy screen are simply useless. I don't mind people to like and buy them, but at least please consider offering a matte version optionally. HP?!?

November 15, 2008 3:35 PM updated: November 15, 2008 3:37 PM

I think the gloss is there for practical reasons, I wouldn't want to touch an anti-glare surface much, it would look awful after a while.

I think the Touchsmart IQ series is a pretty excellent idea, after all the
Touchsmart features are all in a HP application that very likely will be subject to revision over time. So flaws seen now might all be handled by HP in the near future.
There is probably a very good product architecture reason why there isn't a HDMI output.
As a kitchen och hall computer (or the multimedia center of a small flat) these marvels will find good use. And as a killer control centre for a musical jukebox.

February 10, 2009 8:42 PM

Hi Gunar

This is Ahsan(senior sales consultant) iam working with one of hp business partner in UAE and trying to position this product one of the biggest Advertising comapny in the UAE. The product has been qualified but there is small issue that reason iam looking for your advise the box is coming with 64 bit Vista home , is there any possibility to replace the OS with Vista business instead of home and if its ok i want to ask one more question there is some drivers problem or compaitaibility issue with vista business.Thanks in advance waiting for your re

February 11, 2009 1:47 AM

ahsan said: Hi Gunar This is Ahsan(senior sales consultant) iam working with one of hp business partner in UAE and trying to position this product one of the biggest Advertising comapny in the UAE. The product has been qualified but there is small issue that reason iam looking for your advise the box is coming with 64 bit Vista home , is there any possibility to replace the OS with Vista business instead of home and if its ok i want to ask one more question there is some drivers problem or compaitaibility issue with vista business.Thanks in advance waiting for your re

Hello I'm just one potential customer of this kind of product, not a HP rep.  I would assume there's considerable value if the product can come with a certain OS flavour preinstalled. (install time, licening issues, reliability, etc already sorted out). All modification/customisation in the field will reduce sales margin :) So to consider an order option with Vista business would be something for HP to decide upon.  This product has more than Vista in it (HP specific apps and drivers) meaning HP would need to support whatever OS edition you want.

Discussion:    Add a Comment | Back to Top | Comments 1-5 of 5 | Latest Comment

Add Your Reply

(will not be displayed)

Email me when comments are added to this thread

 
 

Please log in or register to participate in this community!

Log In

Remember

Not a member? Sign up!

Did you forget your password?

You can also log in using OpenID.

close this window
close this window